Sunday, 16 August 2015

Countdown: Day Two

With the first of England's warm-up friendlies out of the way, the World Cup now seems truly incipient. We're no longer talking endlessly about the theoretical, we now actually know what England's players look like following the much vaunted beasting in Colorado.

So far, it seems a little mixed.

If I'd written a preview for this game, it would have consisted mainly of mild apathy about the whole affair save for the front row and centres. The front row I liked because, while potentially shaky at the set-piece, it looked on paper like the best carrying front row England's put together for some time, with another decent unit on the bench. Most people seem to forget just how good having Woodman, Thompson and Vickery was back in 2003, but the value of having a front row that really goes through work in the loose is immense. 

I'd say we saw a little of that. Both Webber and Vunipola put in good carrying shifts and Brookes' nine tackles before his injury is matched only by Parling in terms of tackles per minutes. But it wasn't match changing, not in the same way that our set-piece wobbles were, or our problems at the breakdown. The scrum, I would suggest, is just about in credit. The French are arguably the hardest opponents they will face for the rest of the year and they won some to go with their losses on the day. The lineout is a different kettle of fish and, given Hartley's travails in the spring, it's enough to have me mildly worried. It's easy to point at the hooker and scream insults about his ancestry, but it's up to the rest of the forwards to give him confidence and make it easy for him by getting their jobs spot on. That doesn't seem to be happening and asking Cowan-Dickie to go for the tail after a dodgy throw on a five-metre lineout is just not smart. It's as sympathetic as giving a tramp monopoly money. Here's hoping the England lineout is working hard, as Tom Youngs isn't exactly safe from bad throwing himself (even if he did have the highest lineout completion stat in the AP this year).

However, it's at the breakdown and collision that England's forwards really looked dubious. The collision area can be brushed aside a little as we know they'll improve but the breakdown has been a source of continuing angst for England fans for some time. England routinely struggle to get the best out of their own ball with the last Ireland game being a particularly sore reminder if for some reason you recently watched all of it with a definite emphasis on the rucks. Yes, I am that sad.

In the backs, things went better, but then arguably the backs were last challenged. Bar a few early sorties the French never really carved out space to attack out wide (despite twenty minutes of sin-bins) or exploited the slow ball to go hunting half-backs. It was fantastic to see England carve out and take opportunities out wide with the sort of clinical edge that comes and goes with England teams, but it's wait and see how it goes on bigger occasions before getting too jubilant.

The centres, however, might be getting me a little over-eager for the future. Henry Slade has been a star in the making for the last few years and I heard a lot of people grumbling about his absence from the Six Nations squad. He has excellent hands and vision and combines it with very sound defence - a possibly unique combination in English rugby today - and Watson's first try was a perfect example. It's a little risky to take him along without having exposing him to a real test match but even if he does miss out, he'll be pressing hard for the next Six Nations.

As for Burgess - it remains to be seen where his long term position for England will be but it seems increasingly like he will have one. I've seen a lot of predictions that he'd cut and run and all that but the more one hears from him and of him, the more that seems unlikely. He comes across as very dedicated and very honest; I can't see him code hopping like Sonny Bill Williams. The dedication also comes through in how quickly he's learning. I for one never thought he has a realistic hope of making this World Cup but based on that performance, Lancaster would be foolish to leave him behind. The big question for me was whether his defensive alignment would be ok - twelve tackles with no misses suggests it was. He also surprised me with how willing he was to pass. It would be very easy for him to decide he's the biggest back on the pitch and he's taking the ball and going straight (coughManuTuilagicough) but in the event he was pretty sensible and accurate about looking for opportunities to work it to men in space.

Long term, I still think he might be better at blindside. It gives him a bigger scope to be involved in the game and makes it harder for the opposition to line him up. It certainly seems that Bath coach Mike Ford feels that way, although he may change his mind if Eastmond's rumoured move back to League occurs. He might have also changed his mind based on that game; crash centres who can move the ball aren't that common. In any case, that's the future. Can he displace Barritt now? I'm no fan of Barritt, but I'm not sure of that one. It would give England's world cup chances a real boost and that's why it looks like centre might be Burgess' position for England after all. We might be struggling a little at blindside, but nowhere near as much as at centre.

In any case, it's all slightly academic until we see the rest of the squad perform.

Wednesday, 12 November 2014

No More Excuses

It's a harsh thing to say after a 3 point loss to the All Blacks, but England's next game is beginning to look like a line in the sand. Either we show we are capable of beating the SANZAR teams, or the seed of doubt about whether this team has what it takes will start to grow rapidly.

You only have to look at Wales' record under Warren Gatland to see what a habit defeat can be. They've racked up a formidable if inconsistent record in the Six Nations but show them one of the Big Three and the opposite happens; very consistent, not at all formidable. They lose, again and again. Such a fate is unacceptable for most England fans, still dreaming of that brief period when Lord Bald's white orcs ruled the world. But we could be heading for it. No, wait, scratch that. That's where we currently are. The stats don't lie. But, it's acceptable that it takes a coach time to build a team. It's not worrying in the greater scheme of things if its taken Lancaster three years to get to the point of regularly challenging the best. 

However, rebuilding time should have been passed. Maybe people are being hasty, driven by envy of Joe Schmidt taking a formerly-weak Ireland to the Six Nations and a spanking of the Springbok within a year. There are still some big weaknesses in terms of personnel available to Lancaster. But three years is a long time in rugby. You have to go back to the 80s to find an England coach who, given three years, didn't win the Six Nations at least once - save Lancaster. Three years is enough. Besides, Ireland won a Six Nations with their 6th and 7th choice wingers (give or take), Wales won a Grand Slam with Dan Biggar at fly-half. A canny coach can work his way around limited personnel.

The good news is that the Boks look fallible, even if that defeat to Ireland will have their motivation at fever pitch. As everyone knows, they will start by running hard at you and if that doesn't work, they'll run even harder. But that's just not as scary when they don't have Willem Alberts, when de Villiers and Etzebeth look out of sorts, when the good Du Plessis and the precocious Pollard are on the bench. They'll have to be intelligent rather than just brutal, and in Reinach and Lambie they have an untried half-back partnership. The absence of Francois Louw hurts them here too, even if Coetzee is an able deputy. The dubious form of their first choice props won't help them either. In short, while this is still South Africa, it is a South Africa that is missing its shock troops and generals. 

So - if England can't beat them at home when they're a little more tender than usual - when would we be capable of beating them?

Hopefully the question won't arise. It's time that England started winning games like this.


Friday, 3 October 2014

Midland Pests

It has now become apparent that Wasps are very close to sealing a deal to buy Coventry's Ricoh Arena with the intent of moving their games there. It's all been very hush-hush until now and, while that might have been due to commercial imperatives, Wasps must have welcomed the side-effect of avoiding negative opinion and opposition. 

It's not difficult to work out why there might be negative opinion as this move seems utterly idiotic.

Wasps are a west London club. That was confirmed to me every time I spoke to a Wasps fan in London - or even a rugby neutral - about their then mooted move to Brentford and heard hope. Wasps returning home. I'd even been planning to go a few Wasps games if that happened. Some will tell you the move to Wycombe was only ever sold as temporary before finding a London home. Now their club is lining up to tell them they'll be moving even further away.

Meanwhile, there's a large number of Coventry City fans who will be feeling betrayed and hurt if this goes through. The Ricoh, in their eyes, is Coventry's natural ground. To see it handed over to a rugby club from London that doesn't even want to move its training base and players there instead does not sound like the most promising of introductions. Of course, Wasps will mainly be focusing on Coventry's rugby fans. My guess would be there's two kinds of rugby fans in Coventry. There's those who travel to support Northampton, Worcester or Leicester, and who are presumably quite set in their ways. Then there's those who support Coventry, because it's Coventry and they're from Coventry, and Wasps will not be from Coventry. 

One can only presume the Wasps management think it will end out differently. The gods only know why. It's not like they'll even be able to claim they're a proper Coventry club, as apparently they're retaining their London training base. Hi people of Coventry - come and support a bunch of boys from London up here for a day trip! And they certainly wouldn't be a London club, as London clubs play as close to London as possible. You can go out and dress it up better for marketing but that is a difficult and unlovely underlying reality to hide. 

Spare a thought for the players. The commute is probably better than actually moving to Coventry, but no one signed on for that, and you've got to wonder at what point the club would try moving the whole circus there. There are three London clubs who'd probably love to asset strip Wasps if possible. Rumours have it that Saracens are already making overtures to Joe Launchbury, and by rumours I mean Dai Young's said it, who should probably know. Launchbury's wondering whether Wasps are a club with a top 4 future where he can challenge for trophies. If it becomes a tight call, at what point does a schlep up to the Midlands to play in front of an empty stadium enter his thinking?

Of course, while a player might wonder if they've got plans for moving the entire operation up to Coventry at some point, which could be very inconvenient for his family, any new fan in Coventry must wonder whether the retention of a London training base means this too might be temporary 

This could go on and on. There are main potential riffs on the main theme of "Wasps are about to make their club unloved and untrusted" but the owners don't seem to have noticed. Or cared. Or asked. 

And that's pretty shitty.

Here's hoping that it stings them in the arse.

Friday, 31 January 2014

Six Nations 2014: England

This will be Lancaster's third Six Nations as England head coach. It is hard to write anything about his England side without feeling deja vu for so far, the essentials of that side have not truly changed since day one. Since that unlikely, lucky win in the foulest of weather up in Scotland.

Under Lancaster, England have displayed considerable powers of defensive organisation and mental strength. The word incredible might be better; England have racked up a tidy array of wins seemingly by these two qualities alone. When it comes to the art of avoiding defeat by avoiding mistakes, England acknowledge few equals. The same qualities also make England very proficient at forcing such mistakes from their opposition. Their excellence in these areas have been sufficient to deal with a surprising number of teams.

In other areas however, England have looked a long way from excellent, although they do sometimes strain credibility. Place the England team in front of a tight, disciplined defence, give them the ball, and you could be there all day before a try is scored. Which becomes an issue when facing a team composed enough to deal with England's pressure tactics and gifted enough to crack the defence. There isn't a great amount England can do beyond that. The backline in particular has frequently looked more wooden than Keanu Reeves but it should not go unmentioned that the far more vaunted pack has undergone its own set of troubles. Over the past two years it has misfired regularly either at the lineout, the scrum, the breakdown or in terms of ball carrying. It is, in review, a comprehensive gamut of possible errors.

That it, more or less, the pattern of Lancaster's England. Successful when discipline is enough, not when it's not, unable to offer more. There are some outliers - New Zealand seem to bring out our best, there have been a few incidents of minnow trouncing and sometimes the system has failed spectacularly. But the pattern holds and as such, every tournament brings the question of 'Can England break that pattern and move on?' If we are to accomplish Lancaster's goal of winning the World Cup, we have to, and are running out of time to do so.

Lancaster could be forgiven for cursing his luck going into this tournament. There is an extensive injury list, filled with genuinely important players. The absence of Alex Corbisiero is a huge kick to the teeth and although Joe Marler's coninued improvement lessens the blow, he is not at the same level yet in his scrummaging.  Dave Wilson's injury is less newsworthy, but nearly as annoying. Without the Bath tighthead England's resources look very thin. Henry Thomas is a young man of much promise, but he is not here on the back of excellent scrummaging. Until Wilson regains fitness, you would imagine Cole will be played for as long as possible, adding to his already gargantuan workload for club and country. As a platform for attacking rugby, it is not ideal. At least the lineout should function with Hartley at hooker.

The breakdown is a different kettle of fish. Last year, I think, sometime around the Italy game, there was a video with HASK(tm) and Flood going over some of what had gone wrong and right. Numbers at the breakdown was one of the things mentioned with it being acknowledged that England had not sent enough men in. That has been an on and off failing ever since (and was before too) on show as recently as the last Saxons game. You presume they're using the same systems as the senior team. Are we about to see England commit minimum numbers to their own breakdown again? When England undercommit, they get done. There is the mobility and power available to secure the ball, that much is obvious from the most recent New Zealand game, but it is not getting consistently applied. The French may not have Dusautoir but they are still capable of causing major amounts of mischief.

So the platform up front could be shaky. Lancaster will have things to work on in training. Behind the pack, things look very different. The most familiar faces are Danny Care and Owen Farrell, but they are not overly familiar with each other. They have never started a game together before and have racked up less than 140 minutes of gametime as a partnership. The only real continuity in the backline comes in the Farrell-Twelvetrees partnership which has so far notched up five games, including the last three. It seems unlikely that we will see the backline going full tilt as a result.

However, there is nothing new about that. What is new and very laudable, is the danger possessed by each individual player. With the exception of Owen Farrell - and maybe not even that exception - there is no player to which you would wish to offer the gap. Both Burrell and Twelvetrees have power and distribution skills to add to a bit of pace and footwork while the back three is probably the most dangerous fielded by England in a Six Nations game since... since... answers on a postcard please. Nowell is in many ways a similar player to Brown - clever feet, strength and mad determination while Jonny May is just ridiculously fast. This is what many of us have wanted and we should be patient.

So, all in all, it seems unlikely to me that this is the tournament we will see the great step forwards. The platform up front is shakier than one would like and the backline is having to gel together on the job. The half-back partnership is made up of players better known for disappointing fans with their distribution than otherwise. Where we may see a tiny step forwards is that there are more players capable of moments of individual brilliance as the game opens up. Given the pressure England force on teams, seeking to force the game into brief periods of chaos in which they may prosper, this could work out.

But if movement is unsure on England's weaknesses, what then of England's strengths? If Saint-Andre made any prayers towards a choice of opposition for tomorrow, an England backline this callow would have been in his thoughts.  In particular, the centre partnership of Twelvetrees and Burrell looks a little suspect. Burrell started the season as a hard hitter who didn't read the game that well. He's been working on it - but as a 12.  At 13, as the hinge of the defence, things are different. Against them, France will pit Fofana's dancing feet and Bastareud's supersized prop physique, along with the back three popping up where they will. That could end poorly. Judging from the selection of Brad Barritt on the bench, Lancaster also suspects this as a possibility. It is difficult to see a more obvious reason for him being there. If that gap appears, what happens to the team's confidence? Does it affect their discipline? It seems unlikely but it is possible. This backline might just be the gamble of Lancaster's career.

The problems may remain the same but the factors have changed radically. This could be the most interesting Six Nations for England for some time.

Thursday, 23 January 2014

Saxons vs Wolfhounds preview

The time just before the start of the Six Nations is always something of a washout in terms of rugby on the television, so thank gods for the continuation of A rugby in some corners of these isles. The A match between England Saxons and Ireland's Wolfhounds has always been an interesting guide to who the coaches might pick next year but are almost certainly going to ignore this year - which I hope isn't true of Anthony Watson.

The Bath youngster has dropped down from the main squad to cover injuries to the Saxons' initial selection of wingers in the best news that Chris Ashton has had since the double injury to Marland Yarde and Christian Wade last autumn. Watson will link up with Charlie Sharples, possibly the world's fastest bald man, and versatile Wasps man Elliot Daly. Not quite as deadly sounding as the originally mooted Varndell-Rokoduguni-Daly unit but still a worrying sight for oppositions anywhere. It does slightly beg the question of what Ashton is still doing in the senior squad when Charlie Sharples is about our ninth choice winger (Yarde, Wade, Nowell, May, Watson, Benjamin, Varndell, Rokoduguni and then Sharples) who is not Chris Ashton. Still, enough of that.

This Saxons team also contains a first taste of senior representative rugby for Exeter's Sam Hill, the powerful centre who has been a mainstay of England's U20s for the last two season, and probably the fastest possible English half-back pairing around in Joe Simpson and Freddie Burns. Also, Matt Hopper at 13. Up front, Tom Mercey reminds me that he exists and is a real person as he continues his pairing with fellow Northampton bencher Alex Waller, with Saracens' in form Jamie George sandwiched in between. Another Saracen, in the form of George Kruis, partners Charlie Matthews while the back row is made up of huge Exeter 8 Dave Ewers, lassie lookalike Luke Wallace, and Calum "Arm Bar" Clarke, arguably the most despised man in English rugby. Good blindside though.

The bench contains U20s prop Scott Wilson, promoted early for reasons that have absolutely nothing to do with him being eligible for Scotland, Dave Ward of Quins, and Bath loosehead Nathan Catt in the front row. Glaws tyro Elliot Stooke will celebrate a hugely successful 12 months with his first Saxons cap if he comes - watch out for him, anyone who looks good in the current Glaws pack is made of some stuff - while Northampton's Sam Dickinson covers the back row. Dave Lewis of Exeter returns to Kingsholm as scrum-half cover, former U20 fly-half Henry Slade will be looking to link up with Sam Hill off the bench, and Rob Miller makes up the numbers as back-three cover.

Ireland by contrast look a lot more battle hardened. Loosehead Dave Kilcoyne has international caps and will join Rob Herring, the impressive Ulster reserve hooker, and Martin Moore in the front row. Moore in particular has been good recently and looks halfway to usurping Mike Ross for Leinster. The Ulster combination in the engine room of Dan Tuohy and Iain Henderson can also boast a handy collection of international caps and a very impressive level of athleticism. The back-row of Rhys Ruddock, Tommy O'Donnell and Robin Copeland offers a good mix of skills and size and a metric shit ton of carrying. Experienced scrum-half Isaac Boss will be expected to shackle Simpson when not linking up with Leinster team mate Ian Madigan. Darren Cave forms the third part of an international 9-10-12 axis, although not in his usual position, with Robbie Henshaw preferred at outside centre. He too has international caps, as do the wingers Craig Gilroy and Fergus McFadden, an interesting mix of rapier and bludgeon. I can't remember if Felix Jones has any and if he does, he's not getting many more, but he should do his job nicely.

The bench isn't a great deal kinder. It's a delight to see Richardt Strauss return to competitive rugby after a heart condition forced him to spend most of this season out, but I can't help but wish he'd waited a week. Newly minted international prop Jack McGrath will be licking his lips at the thought of getting his shoulders into Scott Wilson while Stephen Archer looks like he might have stopped being the new Tony Buckley. There's no specialist replacement second row, with naturalised Saffa Robbie Diack and Leinster youngster Jordi Murphy on the bench, but Diack or Copeland could fill in there at a pinch. Behind the scrum they have Kieran Marmion, Ian Keatley and Simon Zebo waiting. Keatley is nothing special, Marmion may be and Zebo is - providing he's properly fit.

So what's going to happen? While the Saxons have home advantage, the Wolfhounds have the advantage in terms of experience. They also arguably have the advantage in form with all but three of the players coming from HEC quarter-finalists. A quick count shows only two players from Saracens and Leicester - not helped by a huge injury list that contains Will Fraser, Graham Kitchener, Jamie Gibson, Miles Benjamin and Matthew Tait. The only caps in the England side are Joe Simpson, Freddie Burns and Charlie Sharples. A lot could rest on the half-back pairing, both to guide this team through, and as attacking weapons in their own right. If the Irish fringe defence is weak, they will shred it like pulled pork. It's not a settled defence, with Cave out of position, Henshaw raw, and none of the three used to each other. Henshaw's positioning in particular will be targeted I think and he'd be well advised to keep an eye on Elliot Daly. The second row is arguably not the best for the set piece, although it was that second row that propelled the Ulster front row near clear out of the back of Leicester's set piece the other day.

However there appear to be more weaknesses in the Saxons. The prospect of Wilson vs McGrath is a worrying one. Matt Hopper is given to the odd stupid decision in defence and Burns is no bastion of strength either. Daly's mastery of the full-back position is about to be given a thorough going over by the Irish love of the garryowen. In the pack, we are arguably a little short of carriers, with a huge amount expected from Dave Ewers. Expect the Irish to line him up (maybe a job for Tuohy and Ruddock). Good luck picking an Irishman to line up; they could all make dents. It could be a long day if our inexperience is exploited in a crucial way.

I am not expecting that, although I am worried about it. The breakdown will be crucial with both sides having a few decent jackals - the clash between Wallace and O'Donnell in particular looks a highlight. Whichever side gets clean ball, they have the attacking players to make the most of it, with Madigan and Burns both alike emerging from the Carlos Spencer Appreciation Society school of fly-half. The English back three packs a potent punch (an unusual sight for us) and if we get the ball up front, victory should be ours. But then isn't that true? I look forwards to finding out.

Saturday 25th 17:00, Kingsholm.

England Saxons15 Elliot Daly (London Wasps) 14 Anthony Watson (Bath Rugby) 13 Matt Hopper (Harlequins)12 Sam Hill (Exeter Chiefs) 11 Charlie Sharples (Gloucester Rugby) 10 Freddie Burns (Gloucester Rugby) 9 Joe Simpson (London Wasps) 1 Alex Waller (Northampton Saints) 2 Jamie George (Saracens) 3 Tom Mercey (Northampton Saints) 4 Charlie Matthews (Harlequins) 5 George Kruis (Saracens) 6 Calum Clark (Northampton Saints, captain) 7 Luke Wallace (Harlequins) 8 Dave Ewers (Exeter Chiefs)

Replacements
16 Dave Ward (Harlequins) 17 Nathan Catt (Bath Rugby) 18 Scott Wilson (Newcastle Falcons) 19 Elliott Stooke (Gloucester Rugby) 20 Sam Dickinson (Northampton Saints) 21 Dave Lewis (Exeter Chiefs) 22 Henry Slade (Exeter Chiefs) 23 Rob Miller (Sale Sharks)

Ireland Wolfhounds
15. Felix Jones (Shannon/Munster) 14. Fergus McFadden (Old Belvedere/Leinster) 13. Robbie Henshaw (Buccaneers/Connacht) 12. Darren Cave (Belfast Harlequins/Ulster) 11. Craig Gilroy (Dungannon/Ulster) 10. Ian Madigan (Blackrock College/Leinster) 9. Isaac Boss (Terenure College/Leinster) 1. David Kilcoyne (UL Bohemians/Munster) 2. Rob Herring (Ballynahinch/Ulster) 3. Martin Moore (Lansdowne/Leinster) 4. Iain Henderson (Ballynahinch/Ulster) 5. Dan Tuohy (Ballymena/Ulster) 6. Rhys Ruddock (St. Mary's College/Leinster) (capt) 7. Tommy O'Donnell (UL Bohemians/Munster) 8. Robin Copeland (Cardiff Blues)

Replacements:
16. Richardt Strauss (Old Wesley/Leinster) 17. Jack McGrath (St. Mary's College/Leinster) 18. Stephen Archer (Cork Constitution/Munster) 19. Robbie Diack (Malone/Ulster) 20. Jordi Murphy (Lansdowne/Leinster) 21. Kieran Marmion (Corinthians/Connacht) 22. Ian Keatley (Young Munster/Munster) 23. Simon Zebo (Cork Constitution/Munster)

Monday, 21 October 2013

Two rounds in...

Pool 1

The Pool of Death looks like its produced an early casualty. Ospreys' failure to pick up a single point - not even a losing bonus point at home to Leinster - has surely extinguished any reality of qualification. That away win has left Leinster in the driving seat and it seems unlikely they will be dislodged. The interesting question is how long Castres will retain interest in the tournament as, judging by previous years, the French champions are very quick to send out their reserves and focus on more important matters. If they do, Northampton will be left with two relatively uninterested sides for the final rounds, which may give them a decent shot at at one of the best runners-up finishes. For that to happen though they need to perform against Leinster in the coming back-to-backs. Anything less than five points from those games is probably the end of the road. While Leinster have taken a step back in quality since the successfully defending the trophy, they remain a difficult opponent and will be eager to kill off Northampton's threat to their first place. Getting either the try bonus point at home, or the losing bonus point in Dublin, would be a serious achievement. At the same time, Ospreys will be taking on Castres, and if the Swansea side doesn't roll over they should take points off of them. There is the quality there, even if Gatland will be worried about the form of some of the Welsh stalwarts, and Castres haven't travelled well to date. When that happens, it's likely to take the number of casualties to two, with the real question being whether Northampton makes it three.

Prediction: Leinster should qualify with ease. Northampton can follow them, but it seems more likely they'll only make the Amlin.

Players to watch out for: Jamie Elliot continues to come of age in a reinvigorated Northampton backline, Jack McGrath is making a serious impact when coming on for Cian Healy and hopefully Eli Walker will get a better chance to shine on the wing for Ospreys in the next two rounds.

Pool 2

Cardiff Blues' shock win against Toulon has blown this pool widen open for the moment. Exeter are the biggest beneficiaries, leading the pool after their hammering of Blues and bonus point loss to Glasgow, but with everyone on six or five points it doesn't mean a great deal. Glasgow and Blues will be licking their lips at the prospect of their back-to-back - a double from either side would put them in a great position. That seems more likely for Glasgow, whose hard nosed cohesiveness looks a better bet than Blues' reliance on a handful of Lions, players whose head often looks to be elsewhere. They should be focused for the Heineken Cup though and a home win each looks the most likely outcome. As for Exeter, as cohesive a side as you'll see anywhere right now, the double-header against Toulon is a huge challenge, the stuff of dreams and nightmares alike. Toulon should blow them away, but they are given to sudden, inexplicable bursts of frailty. Exeter do occasionally get blown away by sides with more quality than them but its becoming rarer and rarer. Again, a pair of home wins would surprise no one. Toulon would probably be on top due to bonus points after that but what would happen next is difficult to call. Realistically, with a visit to Toulon to come in the last two rounds, Cardiff need to be well ahead of the pack to get anywhere. That seems quite unlikely and Exeter might be quite pleased to visit them last as desire levels wane. The west country side can realistically target two wins there. A trip to Sandy Park and the visit of Toulon seems less appealing for Glasgow but does leave them with a fighting chance. As for Toulon, the visit of Cardiff should be a ritual sacrifice to revenge, but visiting Scotstoun looks a banana skin. Whatever way it falls, it seems very plausible that the winner and runner-up will bank low points tallies. Drawing Toulon in your home quarter-final? That's what European competition is all about.

Prediction: If I could accurately call this, I would be too busy fleecing bookies to write this. Toulon are the most likely, as bonus point accumulation should see them overcome slip-ups. Realistically, the match ordering probably says no to Exeter, as if they beat Glasgow in Round 5 its difficult to see the Scots doing them a favour by taking down Toulon in Round 6. However, Glasgow themselves could steal through; every match looks winnable for them.

Players to Watch: A good pool for 8s - Robin Copeland of Cardiff and Dave Ewers of Exeter have both won plenty of plaudits. Glasgow's Jonny Gray is still young for a lock, but has the potential to match his older brother Richie.

Pool 3

This pool is now Toulouse's to do with as they will. It's possibly rash to rule out Saracens returning the favour and picking up the away win, and it is certainly the standout tie in Round 5, but Saracens would have to travel a step further than they have ever done to do it. It would be a victory to turn European rugby's head, and I just don't see it happening if Toulouse show up. Yes, Sarries came close at the death in Wembley, but my impression was that they'd done everything they could. In return, Toulouse had been guilty of some stupid rugby and a number of missed kicks. They have another gear left. Mindyou, Farrell missed plenty of kicks as well, any of which would have made a difference. Arguably Toulouse's biggest threat now is Connacht, who have a taste for giant killing and a very unwelcoming climate, tailor-made by God for tripping up better sides. It is not unconceivable that after round 4, Saracens will be sitting pretty after two big wins against Zebre, while Toulouse have tripped up. Which still leaves the question of that trip to the South of France. Realistically, those two games are the group now. Zebre will fight bravely but lack the quality to get anywhere; few Heineken Cup defenders will say they wouldn't be better off in the Amlin. Connacht would need points from visiting Saracens and Toulouse to progress, and either would be the shock of the competition. Toulouse will qualify in some form - 22 points is now a conservative estimate for them. The only question now is whether Saracens will follow them or even take the top spot. At the start of the tournament, it seemed certain they would qualify as best runners up at least. That home loss has cast that into doubt, and Saracens cannot afford any more slip ups.

Prediction: Toulouse should qualify at a canter. Amusingly, it now seems fairly plausible they'd end up seeing Saracens again - Toulouse should get one of the highest group totals and Saracens are still a strong bet for a best runners up slot. However, they need to start picking up plenty of try bonus points for that to happen. 20 points looks a likely total for them. Historically, that's a fairly nervous number to end on.

Players to Watch: Another 8 - Toulouse's blonde roly-poly Gillian Galan made the benching of Picamoles look completely sensible. Connacht's kiwi openside Jake Heenan is adapting to life in Ireland very well, while Saracens lock George Kruis is continuing to build his case as a potential star.

Pool 4

When people described this as a pool of death, I laughed at them, but no one is laughing at the Stoop right now. Visiting Clermont was always a trip for a losing bonus point and little more, but losing at home to Scarlets is simply not good enough for a club of Harlequins' ambition. The exact ins and outs of Harlequins' sudden spiral into shitness would make a blog post all of its own and, while Quins could still win all of their remaining games, Conor O'Shea would probably have to use voodoo for it to happen. Lots of voodoo. Their trip to Paris next round could be one of the games of the contest. Everything rests on it. It should be noted that, for all their money, Racing Metro don't look too hot at the moment. Win that, and anything looks possible. It should be noted that both Racing and Scarlets have their visit to the home of Mandatory Away Defeats to come. Neither side can afford to rest on their laurels if they are to benefit from their strong start. Racing need to keep piling on Quins' misery; a loss in either back-to-back leaves Metro with only three wins at the end. Scarlets have to win at home against Clermont and pray for a strong finish in the last rounds. However, for all that those two sides are currently on top of the group, the real winner from Harlequins' demise is Clermont. Those two home wins are about as safe an assumption as can be. Clermont are not as strong as they were, but they still remain the team to beat in this group. If Quins and Racing can wreck each other's campaigns, then Clermont should breeze on through.

Prediction: Clermont's incredible home record should see them both rule the group and end the hopes of anyone else joining them in the next round.

Players to Watch: Rhys Priestland's return to form could be a massive boost for Welsh rugby. Harlequins lock Charlie Matthews will have a heavy burden placed on his shoulders when he returns to fitness, but he may just be up to it. Bernard le Roux and Alexandre Lapandry, of Racing and Clermont respectively, will be looking to cement their fledgeling international careers with big performances ahead of the Six Nations.

Pool Five

Another potential group of death when drawn, Pool Five has swung Ulster's way after they inflicted Montpellier's first home defeat of the season. The French club, much thought of as dark horses before the tournament, now faces a very uphill struggle indeed. Their third round visit to Welford Road is now a do-or-die mission. They could do it. They have a hugely physical pack, smart half-backs and an exciting back three, but it is far more likely that Cockerill will have worked out how to suffocate them from Ulster's victory. A great match on paper, but Montpellier's hopes are likely to end soon. Treviso's hopes are dead, if they ever were alive, but they remain a difficult opponent who will be looking to take a scalp as a mark of progress. Leicester will hope Ulster trip up in their back-to-back there as, even with just home pride on the line, beating Montpellier away is not an odds-on proposition for the Tigers. So far Leicester are getting what they need without playing particularly well. They do have a long injury list to return but, given the large international contingent the club will send off, it could still get longer. Leicester's chances of qualifying largely rest on how quickly their key men can regain form and fitness and the visit of Ulster to Welford Road. As for Ulster, there are no excuses if they fail to qualify. Their result in Montpellier came from huge defence and excellent tactical discipline, combined with a highly opportunistic and skillful counter-attacking try. The trio of tactical kickers - Jackson, Pienaar and Payne - is now being used as a weapon and Leicester will already be pondering how to deal with them and the kick chase come round six. But then, the group could already be settled by then, if Ulster are clinical and Leicester are not. If it hasn't been, and if both sides hit their peaks, it promises to be a fantastic encounter.

Prediction: Ulster should win this pool now barring a remarkable Leicester resurgence and there is a home quarter-final on the table if they can take it. As for Leicester, if they do the double over Montpellier, a runners-up spot at least opens up, and if they don't it becomes difficult. I'd probably bet against that double.

Players to Watch: Pablo Matera has yet to play for his new club Leicester, but is worth paying attention to if the Rugby Championship is anything to go by. Ulster's Stuart Olding is possibly the least known of the recent batch of youngsters outside the province, and also possibly the best. Finally, Treviso's Alessandro Zanni always struck me as a player who does not get the praise he deserves.

Pool Six

Another tight pool, but once in which Perpignan will be quite pleased by how things are going. That's largely down to Munster's failure to beat Edinburgh away, which surely any eventual group winner will do, but six points from the first two games is a healthy tally in its own right. Perpignan haven't really done much in the past couple of seasons and while they've got a decent team, it's not amazing. A quarter-final appearance would be very welcome, to state the obvious. Perpignan now have Munster back-to-back in what would have been a heavyweight tie four or so years back. Now its a little middle of the road, with Munster getting by more on sheer will than class these days. If either side can win both,games that might be decisive but neither side has an obvious advantage in personnel. Meanwhile, Gloucester can quietly get about the business of stuffing Edinburgh, a team who are not the strongest these days. Two good wins could put them into pole position ahead of the final straight and give them a chance. That's not a given, not when Laidlaw will kick virtually every chance he gets, but its there to be done. There is the talent in Glaws' ranks, assuming their tight five turns up again. If they do, it seems like the group is preparing for a decisive match in the south of France.

Prediction: Perpignan to win it. Possible runners up place for Gloucester if they turn it on, but more likely to be Munster making it into the Amlin.

Players to Watch: Lock Elliot Stooke looks like he might be become a key member of Gloucester's tight five in the next two to three years months, Munster's loosehead James Cronin is beginning to draw quite a lot of hype, and Edinburgh's Matt Scott has occasionally looked very classy at inside-centre.

Wednesday, 11 September 2013

Something Rotten in the State of Europe

The thing I want most from English rugby is for the international team to bestride the world like a colossus. New Zealand? South Africa? Until we can face those teams without expecting the worst, I will not be fully happy. That is the goal. World Domination.

The next thing I want most is for a healthy, competitive league, a league in which the best teams are feared throughout Europe, and the gameplay is something to really tune in for, not to endure.

That's it really. That would be my mission for English rugby.

As such, I am apprehensive and vexed by PRL's decision to abandon negotiations over a new Heineken Cup, instead setting up a new competition with the French that is "open to teams from other countries". We currently have no more details than that, so I'm not going to get carried away in my criticisms. Right now though, it feels a very risky step.

The Heineken Cup and the Amlin Cup have been great things for European rugby as a whole. It has generated money, it has raised standards and it has been a massive hit with the fans. I've been lucky enough to go to two Heineken Cup finals. The amounts of fans from everywhere, come to enjoy the day out, is huge. What is also huge is the intensity of the games. It is the closest thing to international rugby out there - on its days, its equal. English clubs should be in a tournament of this level, and the English national team benefits from its existence.

What are Mark McCafferty and co proposing to replace it with? The French alone seem to me insufficient to create a top quality competition. They were notorious for their tendency to treat the Heineken Cup as a second class competition, saving their best for the Top 14. I can understand the complaints about the Irish doing the opposite to great effect, but it was far better for the Heineken Cup than the attitude of Castres, to pick one repeat offender. The Heineken Cup as it was might have had the odd total non-hacker who did not pack the gear to serve in our beloved cup (here's looking at you, Aironi/Zebre) but between the variety of opposition, the whole-hearted commitment of most teams and the quality at the sharp end it was still a top quality tournament.

Still, what it might lack in quality, it will - to the English clubs at least - compensate for in terms of a big bag of money. Between the BT deal, and a change to the share of the spoils, the financial rewards are considerable. The numbers are foggy - Jeff Probyn goes over them here - but we appear to be talking about an extra £2m a club. When you see how little largesse PRL intended to give to the Pro 12  - a scant £1m extra compared to the £14m earmarked for both the Premiership and the Top 14 - it is no wonder negotiations have collapsed.

One can only take from those figures that negotiations were intended to fail. That the English and French clubs felt their lion's share of the viewing numbers and abilities to get good TV deals entitled them to help stop funding European rugby. That they wanted to move away from a model controlled by the six unions to something under their control. In the process, they are risking much on the Pro 12 countries falling into line and on the disparity of finance not weakening the fragile domestic games of these countries. Without strong domestic games, their long term viability as elite rugby nations comes into question.

Some will see this as fair. The law of the jungle taking over. The same law says that a predator that grows too big for its habitat to support will fail. How is the England team meant to bring itself up to the levels of New Zealand and South Africa if its Six Nation opposition are of poor quality? What glory is there in conquering Europe, when it is simply us and France? The tallest midget is still a very short man. Is the English rugby market worth as much without the Heineken Cup? This is all very worst case, "Union shrinks to League-esque levels of interest" style scenarios, but they are not beyond imagination, and English and European rugby alike will be damaged if they becoe even partially true. 

To me, rugbywise, a strong Europe is the best vehicle for a strong England. A strong Europe provides us with the competition we need, both as a national team, and as clubs. That's what I want for England. Teams that will challenge us. A strong Europe can generate more interest in Italy, with its relatively unexploited TV market. McCafferty and his friends thought the Heineken Cup wasn't generating the money it should. I can agree. It was a fantastic tournament, more varied and tense than the Super XV for my money, and as global interest in rugby rises it was a tournament where tv rights could have been sold abroad. I don't see the same interest in an Anglo-French tournament.

And now, there is no Heineken Cup to sell. Together, we and the French have strangled the goose that lies the golden egg, and put our own bird in place. How this ends, no one can say, because we don't know what the bird looks like.

This is a very hard state of affairs to be optimistic about.

p.s. Some might raise the issue of qualification. I struggle to believe that has been the real issue at any point.

That the Pro 12 clubs have been free to pick HEC games to target without fear of missing qualification targets in the league is an issue. But it is not a very major one; the Irish powerhouses have been able to cruise cheerfully to both play-off berths and European knockout rugby fairly regularly as it stands and it is doubtful that would have changed much. Besides, most media reports indicate the Pro 12 were willing to cave in on this. Issue? Clearly not the major one.

In fact, the main issue with the HEC being a fair competition, if you ask me, is the French being able to spend so much more. No mention of an European wide salary cap though - and by leaving ERC, the English clubs probably left behind their ability to get such a thing.