Tuesday, 29 September 2015

Meet the Ozzies

I'm going to guess most people reading this aren't too familiar with Scott Sio. That's understandable. I'm a rugby nerd with no life and I'm not too familiar with him either. That may change though.

Over the past five years or so, there has been a familiar train of thought for England fans prior to playing Australia and it centered on the scrum. If we beat them convincingly there, we were going to win; if we didn't, we were going to lose. Usually, we would win. Partially that was down to England having a very good scrum, but the pivotal point was more that Australia were absolutely plumbing the depths of forward play. We were far from the only team to benefit from their weakness during that period after all - just think back to Ireland during the last World Cup. Needless to say, Australia haven't enjoyed this, and there's been some considerable efforts to try and fix this. During the Rugby Championship, it looked like these efforts were paying off, and that brings us back to Scott Sio.

Sio is only 23, but to judge from recent selections, he is now Australia's first choice loosehead prop ahead of James Slipper. He might only be a baby in propping terms but having watched him in the Rugby Championship, he's got a bit about him. He's not the finished article yet, nor is he definitely going to be one of the greats, but I wouldn't mind if he was English. I wouldn't be outstandingly nervous if I was an Australian and considering whether he was fit for carrying a nation's hopes on his shoulders.

Scott Sio is a bit of a poster boy for a resurgent Australia pack. They beat the Bokke in South Africa, they beat the All Blacks. They even got two rolling maul tries against Fiji. I don't know to what extent coach Michael Cheika is inheriting the work of others and how much is his work - he made Leinster very hard-nosed in his time there - but either way, Australia are no longer utterly reliant on their backs.

At the other end of the spectrum from Sio is Stephen Moore, Australia's captain and hooker. He started his international career ten years ago and will earn his hundredth cap this tournament all things being equal. That he has survived and prospered in a way no other Australian forward of his generation has is testament to his ability and he is a keystone of this side. 

Surrounding these two men in the tight five are a selection of the slightly journeyman-esque and the slightly Australian. Rob Simmons is an example of the latter and, despite being only 26, the most experienced lock in the Australia camp. He seems to be one of those guys who thrives in the loose and survives in the tight. James Slipper and the injured Will Skelton (now replaced by Sam Carter) also fit that description. In contrast, Dean Mumm spent three years doing the dirty business with Exeter successfully enough. He'll be on the bench, most likely. James Horwill was omitted altogether, despite 61 caps and being the form man from the Rugby Championship. Kane Douglas - who didn't impress Leinster fans at all even before he pleaded to go back home - got the nod instead and will probably join Simmons. Sekope Kepu is likely to be the final piece of the jigsaw at tighthead prop. Nothing about the unit screams danger, but nothing looks weak either. They seem to be at the peak of their powers and if Australia do well this tournament, the country will owe a big debt of thanks to Mario Ledesma, the Argentine scrummaging legend now helping coach the Wallabies.

Behind those men will be Australia's current strongest unit. Michael Hooper has really made a name for himself these past few years, but it was all done in the absence of David Pocock. Cheika has turned the potential selection quandary into a strength by playing the pair of them together and despite both men being officially opensides, their different styles have dovetailed well to date. Hooper is a marauding ball-carrier who loves the loose; Pocock probably the single best player at the breakdown active today. Hooper's decent there too, and Pocock can carry, but each man is concentrating on their strengths here. Hooper's pretty good but, in England's current circumstances, Pocock is the terrifying one. England struggle to protect their own ball at the best of times and Pocock is quite definitely just the worst. A look at the stats here from Green and Gold Rugby show just how much Pocock gets over the ball and just how much damage he does. As someone who loves the breakdown and rugby, it's fantastic to see Pocock playing test rugby again after three years out, but I really fucking wish it was against someone else. Spare a thought for Scott Fardy here, he deserves to be more than the forgotten third wheel; his work rate, grunt, and lineout jumping are the balance this unit needs, and he's performed his role well this summer.

Thankfully if Australia's pack is waxing, their backline is waning a little. Controversy and injury has reaped a bloody toll and the backs that seemed ready to score from anywhere in the first half of this decade look a bit more pedestrian. Will Genia remains scrum-half for now, but even he is not entirely sure how that's come to be, for he's definitely not the same scrum-half that tormented defences back in 2010. Quade Cooper, his old partner-in-cr- no, wait, lets not use that expression with Quade - has fallen even further and will probably be behind Bernard Foley, who's a decent fly-half but not even half the magician that Cooper could be. They'll almost definitely do their job but also almost definitely won't rescue Australia from disaster.

The rest of the backs will probably be made up of Adam Ashley-Cooper and Rob Horne on the wings, Matt Giteau and Tevita Kuridrani in the centres, with Israel Folau at full-back. It's a line up slightly short of game breakers (Folau aside), but one not without its strengths. With the exception of Giteau, that's a number of very solid citizens. Going through them doesn't really appeal. Kicking to them seems even more reckless, with both wingers being difficult to catch out, and Folau insanely dangerous on the counter-attack. It would be nice if we could go around them, as I bet England's wingers are quicker than theirs, but that ideally needs a quick back row to support them, a big centre to fix the drift, and a second playmaker to spread it wide quickly. Australia have that - Kuidrani is very big and Giteau might just be the last of the great 2nd 5/8ths in this increasingly muscled up game. England? Not so much. So we know how Australia will attack (expect Folau to appear outside of 13 a *lot*) - with England, we only know how they'd like to attack.

What England should do, can do, is an open question and one to which I don't have a great answer. I know I can often be a pessimist about English rugby but in this case, it seems well justified to me. They are in better form, strong where we are weak, and without too many obvious weaknesses themselves. The obvious and trite piece of advice for England based on that is 'play out of your skin'. A top level performance from England could still see us hammer into them up front and start dominating the collisions. Tom Wood would be crucial in making that work if he can refind his best form while Joe Launchbury and Ben Morgan urgently need to shake off the rust. Behind the scrum, Henry Slade and Sam Burgess would be my favoured partnership if Joseph isn't available, although the risks are many and obvious.

That said, most teams run risks somewhere in their selection when facing a team of Australia's quality. They have pace, power and precision. They are very strong at the breakdown and in the air with only faint question marks over their set-piece (the lineout faltering against Fiji) and game management. They can score tries through the forwards and maul, they can score them out wide. They're arguably the most in-form team in rugby right now.

It is up to England to prove they belong in this company and stay in the World Cup.

Wednesday, 23 September 2015

Fight fire with...?

There are many ways to measure a player's importance to a team, but one of the best is to think of what happens if they're not there. This is what's about to happen to England with Jonathan Joseph and the more I think about it, the more I fear we're out that Joseph was just about the most important player we had. The worry about Joseph's well-being started for me when Tuilagi was suspended, increased mildly with the dropping of Daly, then spiked when Burrell followed him.

Then I forgot about it. Then Joseph got injured.

Every man and his dog in the press will tell you that Lancaster's planning a midfield of Burgess and Barritt, with Farrell in at ten. It's quite possible this will be confirmed by the time this post is up, given my writing speed. If this is correct, then England will be drastically changing styles at the last minute, just like Johnson did in 2011. That turned out to be a career defining decision for Johnson and that comparison should tell you where I'm fearing this will go but lets look at this coldly and sanely. 

We all know what Wales are bringing. It starts with Jamie Roberts running over the top of someone followed by a similar procession of very big men getting onto the ball in relentless succession until cracks appear. Then they target the crack and try to get one of their speed men through it. Knowing it's about to happen hasn't helped a lot of teams, worn out by the physical collisions and, once upon a time, a scrum led by the might of Adam Jones. The Farrell-Burgess-Barritt unit is very much a case of fight fire with fire. It is the most physical, most anti-Roberts line-up that Lancaster could call on. That's never a bad thing and as someone who has repeatedly pointed to the yards lost by Ford in the tackle, I'd be lying if I said I couldn't see some logic. That said - it's not like we haven't seen Farrell get bounced when going high on a far stronger man. It's even happened to Barritt on occasion. Roberts will not be despairing at the sight of this unit and Gatland will be looking very hard at how to get Burgess to do something stupid in defence.

The real question about the fight fire with fire strategy is what happens when England get the ball in hand and there are weaknesses to all three men selected. The biggest weakness with Farrell is that he's a disruptive selection. Ben Youngs is by now quite used to his ex-Leicester team mate; he hasn't started with Farrell for about two years. Burgess is used to Ford from Bath, but has only started once with Farrell for England. Everything will be that little bit more tentative before we even consider his less assured touch in the role. I've mellowed on Farrell, even if others have become harder on him; he has worked very hard to become an international fly-half. He's developed a running game and has a better range of short passing. He's not as good at either as Ford, but that is forgiveable. Where the difference tells, for me, is what happens when Farrell runs out of instructions. He doesn't look like a natural fly-half at such times. Execute a detailed game plan, yes; produce on the hoof, no. That is part of the reason why he's looked better with a second distributor outside him for England.

He won't have that advantage against Wales. In fact, he'll be so deprived of it, I'm half expected the UN to intervene. The Bosh Brothers (as they're now renamed) will pass, but there is no guarantee of the recipient getting any space to work with. That is a straight-up huge issue for a team whose strongest suit in recent times has been the back three. Wales tend to pick a pretty physical pair of wingers, comfortable with tight spaces, and an outside-centre with the ability to draw a man and pass; they'll be fine. Jonny May and Anthony Watson are not pretty physical. They do not welcome tight spaces. They'd be well forgiven for looking extremely nonplussed when this team is read out, if it wasn't for the fact it's been leaked so thoroughly that the news has been the source of first contact with hitherto unknown tribes in the Amazon. We don't know their language yet, but we're working on it in the presumption they're asking 'what is that bald bloke thinking?'

I had previously defended Burgess' inclusion in the squad on two grounds. The first, that he was no dodgier than any of our other twelves. The second, he probably wasn't going to play in anything important. I told myself that if used, he would at least be with familiar faces from Bath. How utterly foolish I was. Sam Burgess will undoubtedly produce something of worth in attack. No dramas. The question is what will happen when they run the other way and, well, I might be revising my belief he was no dodgier than any of our other twelves. Yes, Burrell and Twelvetrees have made mistakes in defence, but very rarely have they been lining up the wrong man completely. A missed tackle is better than a tackle never made and Nadolo's line break against England exposed that one cruelly. Burgess had no need to buy that dummy and I don't think most other English centres would have. They might have missed the tackle, but at least they'd have slowed Nadolo down. England didn't concede on that occasion. How many occasions will Wales fashion by targeting Burgess though?

It only takes a try or two from that source to undo all the good work that Brad Barritt will do in defence. At that point England need tries of their own and Barritt becomes something of a liability. He tends to prosper more with the additional space at 13, but he still has one of the worst attacking games of any centre at the World Cup. His presence will pile pressure on both Burgess and the wingers, as it will be up to them. The idea - and I'm not ruling out the possibility of it working - is that Barritt will keep his wayward colleague in line in defence, and be able to rely on him to carry the brunt in attack. If that works, England won't be too badly off although it still isn't ideal. If it goes the other way as I've suggested, then England are quite, quite screwed. Either way, we seem committed to meeting the Welsh midfield head on, which is their area of strength. They've been doing it for longer and they've been doing it better. Even if everything works the way it's meant to, they could still beat us there.

Could anything else have been done? We were still probably committed to one of those two players, but there were other options available to allow us to attack Wales in other areas.

The first and most obvious was Henry Slade, who secured his World Cup slot on the back of his performance playing 13 outside Burgess. A fly-half by youthful training, Slade would hugely increase England's ability to vary the point of attack. It seems likely that the wingers would have been far happier to see him there. He would have also offered another tactical kicking option - and it looks like there might be a lot of kicking - and could have had a go at the penalties from half-way that Farrell doesn't have a realistic hope of slotting. It wouldn't have been a solely attacking measure either. Slade's a lot tougher than his slight frame indicates and he established a mean defensive reputation when shutting down Tuilagi in the Premiership last season. Barritt-Slade would have been defensively stronger and Burgess-Slade stronger in attack for definite than the Bosh Brothers.

The other option also involves a West Country boy: Jack Nowell. He looked pretty useful togging out at 13 for the Chiefs at the end of the season and is by far the most like for like choice to replace Joseph. Fast, powerful for his size, good feet and links well. He might not have played the position enough to be a completely comfortable fit on defence, but if we're expecting Barritt to keep Burgess in line, then doing the same for Nowell would be child's play. The best thing about playing Nowell there is England's attacking patterns would have required very little adjustment. Once again, Nowell would make sense for a day with a lot of kicking - see Joe Schmidt's patented 'every back a full back' unit to see how it works.

You could have even played the two Exeter boys together, although that's a little risky for my blood, particularly with no big wingers for crash ball (my kingdom for Semesa Rokoduguni). You could have slotted Farrell into 12 for ultra-conservative defence and kicking game. There were a lot of options other than Fight Fire With Fire. We could have had an Escape. We didn't need to be Trapped Under Ice. There shouldn't be this disturbing sense of Creeping Death coming up on us; that England are about to Ride the Lightning. 

This isn't a definitively match losing selection but I'd have felt a lot more comfortable with the added dimensions and extra defensive security that I think we'd have got from a different unit to the Bosh Brothers. Burgess is going to have to go very well in attack to persuade me I was wrong after the match and I'm really not sure Wales are going to be that susceptible to his straight line running. I've gone from feeling very secure in this match-up, particularly with Wales' godawful luck with injuries, to feeling a bit 50-50. Welsh fans seem a lot more confident now.

To finish on an even grimmer note - if this goes wrong, Lancaster is going to face a lot of hostility. The cries of favouritism and u-turn have already begun, before we even know whether the result justifies the selection. They will only double if he keeps faith with an underperforming pack as well, making Ford a scapegoat. It's certainly not popular; it's dubious whether it's good rugby. Whether this selection is right or wrong, we know Lancaster has made a big mistake, and the question is whether he's fixing the mistake or making the mistake. If he is making a mistake, then England will be half-out of their group, and Lancaster may be finding out For Whom The Bell Tolls.


p.s. This author is in no way ashamed about making so many lame Metallica puns.




Tuesday, 22 September 2015

The Bravest Of Blossoms

I work in an office where conversation is mostly dominated by blaming others, hatred of our environment, and football. I am fairly sure I was only hired to give the other Crystal Palace fan someone to talk to. I  can count the number of informative conversations I've had about rugby there on Oscar Pistorius' toes. Yet the first thing I heard when walking in on Saturday night was an excited conversation about the Japan - South Africa game. I had a long email chain with a friend about just how pumped up he was from watching it. There was a level of general enthusiasm about rugby that I don't always see at my rugby club.

Up until that point, it didn't feel like the Rugby World Cup had grabbed people's attention. There weren't many ads, I didn't hear people talk about it, media coverage was uneven. It feels different now. It feels like Japan has grabbed England's attention.It certainly grabbed my Facebook feed. Given most of my friendships were made at one of a grammar school, a rugby club, or the Officer Training Corps, that's not that surprising, but it backs up the general feeling I'm getting from the media, forums, everyday conversations. 

The RFU constantly talks about legacy - the hope that this World Cup will somehow provide the Big Bang that makes rugby big. Maybe even football big. Provide a second 2003, since they didn't really capture the momentum from the first one. You hear it from World Rugby too - the desire to capture more of the globe, get more of the world involved. Japan just gave both bodies the biggest gift it could have hoped for. Even if the history isn't as readily appreciable to those less involved in the game, the drama cut through all barriers. How can you not love a team that backs itself so readily?

It's a flagship game. If you're talking to someone who doesn't like rugby union, point them to the last twenty minutes of it and if they don't feel something positive watching it, then, well, there's just no hope for some people. It's dramatic, it's poignant, it's immensely entertaining - and it's not just the British Empire Old Boys club either. It might not have grabbed the world's attention - Americans seem oblivious based on my limited polling, but then that's easy when you're country is the size of a continent, with MAAR's new foreign correspondent reporting they weren't 'even aware of the pig thing until I started going round telling people "David Cameron fucked a pig!"' Now he has something more interesting to talk about.

What does it mean for Japan itself? They have the professional infrastructure and the funding to be as good as anyone; the decision to award them the next World Cup echoes that. This isn't like the Pacific Islands, forever hamstrung by populations that don't even break into the millions. Their professional game is in ruder health than about half of Tier One by some standards. Yet, eye-catching as this victory was, they couldn't beat any of the Pacific Islands in the summer, with their only victory in the Pacific Nations Cup coming against Canada. The Japanese game needs more of something and what that something is, I don't know. I don't think many people know. Japanese rugby is a surprisingly big fish in our little pond but one that rarely attracts much attention, which says everything we need to know about Japanese rugby to date.

Japan have made history with this result. Hopefully we will look back and see it as even more historic than it now seems.

Tuesday, 8 September 2015

Weekend Round-Up

Given a full weekend of international action, I only watched one match, and that was Ulster vs Ospreys. Apparently I value sleep over watching England play. Anyway, I mention the Ulster match as before that game, most of Ulster's support was showing distinct signs of anxiety following a very casual couple of warm-ups. Ulster then went on to roflstomp the poor Ospreys and now all is well. The moral of this story is 'think very hard before assigning importance to warm-ups'.

So in that spirit, I will now proceed to talk about games I didn't even see.

From everything I've read, it doesn't sound like Ireland pushed England too hard. The moral importance of this game as a launchpad will be talked up but as a guide of what to expect, it remains a little shaky. It's like John Wanamaker nearly said: half the analysis I spend on warm-ups is wasted, the trouble is I don't know which half. The three things I have been more interested in reading about after the game are the things where I think this is the most accurate guide we've got. They are:

  1. Is Ben Morgan fit?
  2. Did we look like shaking off the self-inflicted wounds in the set-piece, discipline and finishing areas?
  3. How did the centre pairing we've never seen before go?
The answers appear to be:


  1. Getting there. This is important to me as I believe him to be quite comfortably England's best ball carrier.
  2. 100pc in the lineout and only six penalties conceded - good. Losing two of your own scrums and only two tries off of 9 line breaks and 55pc of the territory - not good. 
  3. Seems to be an area of contention. Since I didn't see it, I will hold my peace here, but the whole situation makes me nervous.
In fact, the best news for England's World Cup campaign came from Cardiff, not Twickenham. That's a nasty way to spin the injuries to Webb and Halfpenny and I really would have rather seen them go but it hasn't happened that way and England's chances improve as a result. It's quite possible the Welsh will line up for our game without Samson Lee, AWJ, Webb, Jon Davies and Halfpenny; even if some of them make it, their training will be disrupted. That's a huge loss for the Welsh and while I'm not writing them off, it should definitely tilt things in England's advantage.

Going back to England's opponents from the other day now and I doubt the Irish camp will be as upset as some of their fans seem to be. They have longer to wait for a difficult match than just about anyone else and not only does that give them plenty of time to get things right, it also means they don't want to be completely right just now. If they peak now, they risk being too tired come the big games at the end (assuming they get there). Yes, they might be making a mistake with their build-up - or they might still be the same beast that has strangled the life out of the majority of its opponents over the last twelve months. My bet would be that the coach who masterminded the latter is too canny to be caught doing the former.

That leaves one member of the Home Nations unconsidered - Scotland - and they will be kicking themselves after they snatched another defeat from the jaws of victory. Their propensity for doing so makes them ideal quarter-final opponents for England, assuming everything goes right, but I'm too cynical to leave it there. After all, Scotland do have some serious talent, and the last two World Cups have seen a team step up big style. In Vern Cotter they have their best coach since people liked Tony Blair, if not longer, and he clearly has a plan for his new charges, and I don't mean just "replace all of the Scots with better rugby players", although that does seem to be part of it. It seems a little early for his plans to come to fruition, but then it always does until it happens. It's to be quite devoutly hoped that, when push comes to shove, the main thing Cotter brings from his Clermont days is the ability to lose the majority of important games. 

In other news, most of Europe's major club competitions are now underway, except for the Aviva Premiership. This is a serious relief to me. Some people don't like the leagues playing at these times because they feel the fans get short changed but me, I actively enjoy it. Yes, I'm no longer watching the best vs the best, but that's actually a bit of a benefit. Those games often have something of a predictable feeling to them. Everyone knows what a full strength Saracens or Bath are going to do. That's not something you can say when Ulster put out a reserve back three player at fly-half and hand goal kicking duties to their bosh inside-centre. I don't want that experience all the time, but every now and again, it's really good. 

As it happens, as an Ulster fan, I was immensely happy with how that combination went down. In particular, I would like to take the opportunity to gush about said bosh inside-centre, Stuart McCloskey. It's doing him a bit of a disservice to call him a bosh player, actually. Yes, he is rather powerful - just see here:



But he also plays like a genuine centre. He looks for space, he looks for offloads, he can pass and kick and the rest of it. He just happens to be the same size as the average blindside flanker at the same time. It is a potent combination and a lot of people seem to be tentatively pencilling him in for Ireland in the near future as a result. The interesting part for most people (other than dat hand-off - goodbye poor Welshman) is how he developed - after all, everyone wants a genuinely skilled old school centre who just happens to be the same size as Stonehenge. McCloskey's school days were spent as a scrum-half prior to what must have been the mother of all growth spurts. Imagine what they must have spent feeding him at that point! Mrs McCloskey's weekly shop is not the point here though. The point is that in an era when many of England's groomed from birth superstars seem to have embarassing gaps in their skillsets, and most of the AP's most devastating carriers didn't come through England's academies, it does offer food for thought. No answers yet though. In any case, if McCloskey does keep on developing like this, he'll be one to follow for rugby fans everywhere.

Aside from the Pro 12, we also have the French leagues, and the Championship. I guess calling the Championship a major league is stretching it a little, but it is probably one of the top five leagues in Europe and will be minus a few players over the World Cup. The big loser there is, unsuprisingly, Bristol. In fact, Bristol are the main reason I'm bringing up the Championship. I don't follow the Championship that well, because I'm not too familiar with the teams, but most rugby fans are familiar with Bristol and just how much absurdly bigger than the rest of the Championship they are. Right now, the Championship is like watching an 800lb gorilla smashing itself against the walls of its cage, while all the other inhabitants slip through the bars. It's kind of funny, in a mean way, but at some point the joke will get thin, particularly for the residents of Bristol. It would be great if Bristol could stop Clermonting it up and get promoted before that point, as they do have a lot to add to English rugby. For now though, the joke remains funny, particularly if you're Bedford, who beat Bristol in this first round of the season. That might just be the only time Bristol lose this season though - until the next play-offs.

And that's everything remotely interesting I have to say.

Thursday, 27 August 2015

Countdown: Day Thirteen

The England squad has been announced and the speculation is over - now, let the rage begin! Ok, lets not. I could, but I'm not sure anyone actually wants to read about every mistake I think Lancaster has made. Lets just discuss the squad and stuff. 

First off, the actual squad:

Forwards:
Kieran Brookes (Northampton Saints, 10 caps), Dan Cole (Leicester Tigers, 51 caps), Joe Marler (Harlequins, 32 caps), Mako Vunipola (Saracens, 22 caps), David Wilson (Bath Rugby, 43 caps), Jamie George (Saracens, 1 cap), Rob Webber (Bath Rugby, 13 caps), Tom Youngs (Leicester Tigers, 23 caps), George Kruis (Saracens, 8 caps), Joe Launchbury (Wasps, 23 caps), Courtney Lawes (Northampton Saints, 39 caps), Geoff Parling (Exeter Chiefs, 24 caps). James Haskell (Wasps, 60 caps), Ben Morgan (Gloucester Rugby, 28 caps), Chris Robshaw (captain, Harlequins, 38 caps), Billy Vunipola (Saracens, 18 caps), Tom Wood (Northampton Saints, 37 caps)

Backs:
Danny Care (Harlequins, 52 caps), Richard Wigglesworth (Saracens, 22 caps), Ben Youngs (Leicester Tigers, 48 caps), Owen Farrell (Saracens, 30 caps), George Ford (Bath Rugby, 12 caps), Brad Barritt (Saracens, 22 caps), Sam Burgess (Bath Rugby, 1 cap), Jonathan Joseph (Bath Rugby, 12 caps), Henry Slade (Exeter Chiefs, 1 cap), Mike Brown (Harlequins, 38 caps), Alex Goode (Saracens, 18 caps), Jonny May (Gloucester Rugby, 15 caps), Jack Nowell (Exeter Chiefs, 9 caps), Anthony Watson (Bath Rugby, 10 caps)


Right now, I don't feel too arsed about who didn't make it, in that anyone who didn't make it was only really battling to play Uruguay anyway. Do I think Cipriani should have gone? Yes, I think he'd  have been in my 23 actually, but since Lancaster clearly didn't want him there, I'll have to trust he knows what he's doing. Attwood is unfortunate to miss out as the only lock with a real impact in the tight and I'd have liked him as an impact sub, but there we go. Cowan-Dickie wasn't ready, Corbisiero hasn't recovered enough, Easter is unlucky to be behind two great players, Clark is unlucky that Lancaster doesn't rate him that highly, while Burrell and Twelvetrees have made too many errors. So be it. They were only going to play Uruguay anyway most like.

What do we have then?

The good points are the tight five are very quick for their positions, by and large, and won't give away much in defence. We'll get some real carrying impact out of our bench front row and presumably whichever of the Flowerpot Men doesn't start. In the backs, there's a lot of pace and if we can work the ball wide quickly, we'll cause trouble. Youngs and Ford looked a decent combo in the spring, really working the fringes. Both Ford and Farrell are 80pc kickers this season, so I imagine we'll take our points when on offer.

The bad is that outside of front row subs and the flowerpot men, we don't really offer impressive physical ball carrying. Yes, Burgess is a monster, but I don't expect him to start - which makes all the sucking of breath really odd. Take away the name and story, and people are focusing all their attention on England's second choice centre. That's pretty weird, right? Meanwhile, back with actual rugby, if we're going to get the ball wide, we could really do with more playmakers in the backline. Slade's a fine one, but he's probably not about to start either. They'll make Uruguay wish they'd never been born, but elsewise they'll see more action with the tackle pads than anything else most like. The somewhat one-paced nature of our flankers is a bit of an issue for going wide as well. 

If England can defend stoutly and move the ball wide quickly off of the turnover, set piece, and quick ball provided by Vunipola and Haskell, we're in business. If a team manages to stop those guys and attack our crumbly looking lineout, we have issues. The issues multiply if recent poor discipline continues and renders our defence pointless. That is where we are with this squad. Another way of looking at it is this is our 6N squad only with our first choice locks, Morgan on the bench, Hartley out, and Barritt for Burrell. Most of that's improvement, with the locks and Barritt in particular helping defence and the omission of Hartley particularly helps discipline. That one's funny because its true.

So all in all, it's not too bad. I don't think we're doing the exact right thing, but we're doing something that could work and that's good enough. There comes a time when one must put aside critical thought and misgivings and rally firmly to the flag, such as charging out of a trench or voting for a politician. I might have not posted on this blog for most of a year due to not having anything nice to say about Lancaster, but he's the man, this is his squad and its well capable of making us all very happy. By beating Wales and Australia. If that's not joy for an Englishman, I don't know what is. It might even win the World Cup, although I think we'll need a few breakout performances for that.

However, since I can't resist scratching away at scabs, here's a quick list of what's currently rolling by on the conveyor belt next to the microwave as we see what we could have had...

Forwards:
Cooper-Woolley, Corbisiero, Mullan, Thomas, Waller
Cowan-Dickie, Hartley, Taylor
Attwood, Itoje, Kitchener, Slater
Armitage, Beaumont, Croft, Easter, Kvesic

Backs:
Chudley, Dickson, Simpson
Burns, Cipriani, Flood
Daly, Hill, Tuilagi
Foden, Rokoduguni, Tait, Wade, Yarde

There's a fair few players there I wish that, on peak form and available, had been involved to be honest, and that's without including Delon the Felon and Chris Pennell. Quite what Alex Goode is doing in a list of the best five English full-backs would confound me, nevermind his presence in that squad. A fit Corbisiero was one of our best bets for a World Class player, along with Tuilagi and Croft (I'll fight anyone who says otherwise). 

I won't miss Hartley, who wasn't even throwing that well in the 6N, but apparently everyone else missed that and thinks they will. Whatever - although I would point out that only missing the Fiji game was hardly the end of the world for selection purposes. Quite what Lancaster was thinking I don't know, as maybe it was just irritation masked as selection. It's still pretty weird to think we actually cited a first choice international for such a petty and unreported incident, when you consider the ARU delaying a citing committee so that Michael Hooper could be picked to play for Manly and serve that game as a suspension instead. Suspending Tuilagi for assaulting police officers probably is fair though although I wonder if everyone else would have; it's a shame it's not thirty years ago, when the only punishment he'd have received would have been a beasting from the Kangaroo court then being made social secretary on the next tour.

Elsewhere in that squad are our only two grunt locks of note, our only physical wingers of note, our best utility backs outside 10, and our only out and out continuity opensides. I'm not sure whether to blame Armitage for staying in France or Lancaster for not levering him out - in any case, we knew he wasn't being selected and we knew why, but I'd have loved to have known how good he could have been for us. In fact, there's quite a lot of players I'd  have loved to have involved. Most of those choices were made long ago though so it might be time to jump on the team and come in for the big win, Full Metal Jacket style. We're gonna win the World Cup and Haskell's gonna make Robshaw kill a wounded sniper.

So, come on England. Yeah. Enthusiasm.


Ok, now I'm a bit more excited.

Sunday, 23 August 2015

Countdown: Day Nine

Last night, England were the equivalent of a man who sits next to you on a night bus and promptly passes out and defecates in the smelliest, runniest possible fashion. There were plenty of other seats available, but no, England sat next to you and penned you in next to their effluent stained semi corpse. On balance, England really were that awful.

There are two ways of viewing such an abysmal display.

The first is that England were genuinely trying as hard as they could and that this might just be as good as they can play right now.

The second is that they were a little slack and complacent due to it being a pre-season friendly and that England can play a lot better than that.

The first is very worrying, the second is just irritating. We won't know until we see them play again, but I've seen a lot more teams look a bit lacking in pre-season than I have simply forget how to play rugby overnight. So I'm not worried. This could be wrong, because it can happen; Ireland's 2007 world cup showed that (and there's some parallels to be drawn in the build up). But the second seems more likely. So enough of that and onto something more interesting, namely Danny Cipriani and all he represents.

I thought Cipriani was comfortably England's best player on the pitch yesterday. That smells of damning with faint praise, so I'll rephrase - he was really good. He ran effectively, he created for others and he made good decisions. England looked twice as dangerous with him on the pitch. In terms of attack, Cipriani did everything he could to get into that squad. Whether he has, I don't know, and given the complexities, I'm fairly relaxed either way. Sometimes good players don't make it.

What I'm not relaxed about though is the prospect that there'll be virtually no players like Cipriani - that is to say, playmakers outside 10. At the moment, England are looking at four such - Cipriani, Slade, Twelvetrees and Goode - and I wouldn't be surprised to see only Goode get the nod. Which given that Goode's playmaking abilities have always existed more in theory than in practice for England, could mean no second playmaker at all.

That's beginning to look like a mistake. Last week, we looked dangerous with three guys capable of playing fly-half. This week, we only started making inroads once we had three guys capable of playing fly-half on the pitch. That's hardly conclusive evidence to say the least but it is a solid option for us. Consider too that both of our first choice fly-halves like having a second playmaker and play with one for their clubs. Farrell has Goode to work with at Saracens, Ford works very much in tandem with Eastmond. Both are young men, the sort of player who'd benefit from having a guy to share the burden. Farrell is still not the most fluent playmaker in the world and has played his best rugby for England with Twelvetrees at twelve. As for Ford, he may be as natural a playmaker as you'll see, but he's at his best running at the line and breaking himself or picking a short pass. At Bath, he relies on Eastmond to call the wide opportunities and release the strike runners, as first and best explained to me here. For England, he's been something of a one man show. He's had a lot of success with it so far, but there will be bad days and good days. We saw a bad day yesterday; it was very nearly turned into a good day by Cipriani.

Hell, go back to 2003. Wilkinson, then a better and more experienced fly-half, needed Mike Catt to help him get England over the line. Yes, that was much for his boot as anything, but the crucial thing was he took the pressure off a little. Yesterday, Ford didn't deal well with the pressure. Farrell does have a good big match temperament, but I've seen him struggle in big games too. The second playmaker isn't just about scoring mad tries y'all. It's about making life easier for the main man as he controls the game. Ultimately, it's a necessary option. Even if we don't start with it, we want it on the bench. But we might be about to all but give that up.

Going back to Cipriani - he would be an excellent option there. He brings a lot of experience and maturity to the role these days and his broken play running means he'll demand more attention than the other options. All of the options have their strengths, but Cipriani might be the strongest.

In fact, I think Cipriani might be our strongest fly-half. Of course, we don't know. We haven't played him there enough to find out. However, if you believe like me that Farrell lacks the instinctive creative impulses and skills needed to be the very best, and are worrying about Ford's defence and big game freedom, then maybe England need a better fly-half. Cipriani has done very well for Sale this year, in a harder environment than either of his younger rivals. His defence is much improved, his instincts and skillset impeccable - and his experience possibly invaluable. Could he been our man? I would like him to get the chance this World Cup, albeit in a impact sub role. I won't cry if he doesn't get it, but it's what I'd do. Cipriani for England.

Anyway - a quick look at the others. Attwood looked good, but he always looks good as an impact sub and disappoints as a starter. Might have definitely grabbed his slot from Kruis. Easter will be useful if Morgan doesn't make it. Jack Nowell continues to look a proper player. Haskell was our standout starting forward, which is a weird place. Discipline was awful, per usual.

Finally, the lineout. I'm sick of talking about the lineout. I'm sick of watching England waste possession.

Mostly though, i'm sick of watching people blame the hookers. Over the last seven games, it's looked bad. There's been five hookers involved. Five. If five guys use a system and all get bad results, why blame the man and ignore the system? There's been a lot of pundits sucking the air in between their teeth and going "Nah darling, that Tom Youngs' throwing can't be repaired, totally blown" and conveniently ignoring Youngs being the most accurate thrower in the AP last season. So, dear world, please stop blaming the hooker for everything and saying Dylan Hartley is the solution, despite last Six Nations, you dumb fucks. 

Saturday, 22 August 2015

Countdown: Day Eight

I could do people a big long preview of Le Crunch part 2, but I figure there's not a lot of point. It's a pre-season friendly between two teams who play each other a lot, and with both teams at close to full strength, everyone knows what to expect. I'm sure there'll be something interesting to talk about after the match but I don't really know what it is right now. If I did, I'd probably be too busy fleecing bookies. So stuff previews. I'm pretty sure you're not mean to open articles with negative rambles about what you're not going to talk about, but there we go. Maybe it's some avant-garde bullshit.

What I am going to talk about are the players to whom today really matters. Some of them are pretty secure and just there for the run out. Dan Cole could probably concede a penalty at every scrum and still start in the World Cup. But today, some of them will fight for their dreams - and some of them will see their dreams die. DRAMA.

Jamie George

Jamie George is not fighting for his dream of going to the World Cup and that's pretty much been the case ever since Luke Cowan-Dickie picked a really bad game to get his throwing wrong. George will have to be actively trying to make a mess of it to miss the squad now. His dream will be to challenge Rob Webber and get a place in the match day 23 and right now, that seems pretty feasible. Going by selection, Webber seems to be a player than the management like but don't love. The Bath hooker probably has the edge at the moment thanks to experience, but a big game from the bench could change that.

Of course, the real prize here for George isn't just the World Cup, it's about nailing down a long term place while the older competition falters and before his younger rivals show up. Webber might not get back the Bath starting spot he lost to Ross Batty at the end of last season, which would really crimp his style. Meanwhile, Dylan Hartley must surely be beginning to try Lancaster's patience. I'm not predicting it to definitely happen, but it wouldn't be a surprise if neither man was involved come next autumn. There's a fair crop of young hookers waiting to exploit that - Sale's Tommy Taylor and Hartley's understudy Haywood both spring to mind - but George has first go and has earned it. His throwing has been accurate, his work rate very high and his carrying game strong. It's within his potential to finish this World Cup as a rival to Youngs - but only if he gets it right today.

Joe Launchbury

Ok, I might be stretching this one a little, but I really like talking about Joe Launchbury so whatever. In any case, everyone's favourite mutant thirteen year old has been out of contention for a bit, and therefore he does have something to prove. Just that in his case, all he has to do is to show he's still got it and we can all be happy that the closest thing England have to an openside in the squad is back.

In fact, not only will he be back, but to judge from the RFU's stats, he and a little extra will be back. He's now allegedly just over 18 and a half stone and if he's retained his pace, he should be a very unpleasant person to run into. It might also bring an improvement in Launchbury's tight play, which maybe hasn't been his strong suit. If these things have happened, then I might finally put him in the same bracket as Retallick and Etzebeth.

James Haskell

Also not at risk of missing out barring a horror show, this is all about Haskell nailing down the 6 jersey. So far, he's never worn it in a serious game when Wood has been available and Lancaster head honcho. His presence today suggests this may have changed but it's probably best not to assume, particularly with Lancaster constantly talking about starting the flowerpot men. So a big performance is needed today - but really, what I'd really like to see from Haskell, is that string of big performances he's been threatening his whole career. 

Danny Cipriani

Very much at risk. That he's England's third fly-half is currently beyond doubt but it's clear that the management are happy to do without their third choice if they can get more strength in the squad from somebody else who can fill in there if needed. Say, Henry Slade or Alex Goode, both of whom had good games last time out. When CIpriani turned down Toulon, with their pots of gold and cabinets of silver, this probably wasn't what he had in mind. But he is here now.

Maybe this second chance points to the England management wanting to take him. To my mind, it'll be instructive to see where they put him on, and I think full-back would actually be better news for Cipriani. While there's no doubt he's stronger at fly-half, no one cares. The question is whether he's strong enough at full-back to cover both. If he can shine there, he's got a good chance of going - and why not? He's quicker and more elusive than Goode and just as good a playmaker. The question lies in his defensive duties, particularly against the kicking game, and I suspect that's what Lancaster will be judging. If he does goes well, Cipriani might be well advised to remember just how old most of England's full-backs are; it's probably going to be the easiest route into the team over the next four years.

Tweedletrees and Tweedlethump

Neither Burrell nor Twelvetrees will have enjoyed watching Burgess and Slade last week with a whole heart. However, that's now gone, and so too are our promising centres; it's up to the old guard in their chance to redeem themselves. Which seems odd; both Burgess and Slade demand further investigation in my eyes. Meanwhile, Burrell's been showing off poor ball protection and poorer tackling for England, while Twelvetrees is a law unto god alone.

Still, here they are and truth told, I'm not quite sure what Lancaster's looking for. I rate both guys at their best, but the likelihood of getting their best seems too low, or even just an above average international game, and I'd have dumped them by now. However, I do think he sees this as a play-off for one spot and given that Lancaster is supposedly looking for four centres and has given Cipriani another go, I'm not sure this bodes too well for Henry Slade. I'll burn that bridge when I get to it, but I'm increasingly unimpressed with such a notion.

Jonny May

Finally, Jonny May. Now, Jonny isn't even remotely fighting for his space in the squad, not with three wingers kept. Short of being unveiled as people traffickers, all three guys are in. The argument's about who starts the big games and its now up to Jonny to seal the deal. It doesn't even have to be a big game from him, although you'd get excited about his form if he did.

It just needs to be solid. Everyone knows that he's deadly coming round into the 13 channel, that he's got incredible feet at more or less full tilt and his full tilt is elite by rugby standards. I'd like to think appreciation for his kickchasing (for which he's peerless in this England squad) and use of the touchline as a defender will grow. May didn't lose his place in the England team because of those things though. He lost it because he was making mistakes when the game contracted. Given that England have gone from three playmakers to one outside scrum-half, the space May will get today will probably contract. If May can't deal with that, his career as an international wing will always be precarious.


Anyway, I lied. Most of these people aren't playing for their spot in the squad, just jockeying over position within. Still, what's informative writing without DRAMA? That's what the Mail tells me. Maybe next week I'll blame it all on immigrants and women and my infection by the Mail will be complete.

Until then.